top of page
  • Writer's pictureJennifer Ball

Cedar vs. Pine Fences: The Ultimate Showdown

Cedar and Pine wood

Welcome back to The Fence Company blog! If you're here, chances are you're on a quest to find the perfect wood fence for your property. You've narrowed it down to two contenders: Pine and Cedar. It's the classic showdown, like Batman vs. Superman, but with fewer capes and more wood. Let's dive in and see which one comes out on top in the cedar vs. pine fence debate!

Round 1: Appearance

Pine Fences

Pine fences are like that friend who always wears a crisp, white shirt—clean, fresh, and classic. Pine wood has a very light brown, yellowish hue that can brighten up your yard. It's like the Golden Retriever of woods—friendly, approachable, and it just makes you feel good. However, pine fence cons include the need for frequent maintenance to maintain its appearance.

Pine fencing is versatile and can be painted or stained to match your yard's aesthetic. Whether you prefer a natural look or a bold color, pine fences can adapt to your style. However, keep in mind that pine wood, being a softer wood type, can show wear and tear more quickly than its cedar counterpart.

Cedar Fences

Cedar, on the other hand, is like the James Bond of woods—sophisticated, rich, and a little bit mysterious. With its reddish-brown tones, cedar fence options add a touch of elegance to any setting. Plus, it ages like fine wine, turning a beautiful silvery gray over time. Western red cedar fence options are particularly popular for their beautiful grain pattern and natural beauty. Cedar planks are a top choice for those seeking a stylish and durable option.

Cedar wood also has a unique grain that adds to its visual appeal. The natural beauty of cedar fences makes them a standout feature in any yard. They offer a timeless look that can enhance your home's curb appeal and make your outdoor space more inviting.

Round 2: Durability

Pine Fences

Pine might be the underdog in this round. It's a softwood, which means it's more susceptible to dings, dents, and those inevitable backyard football collisions. However, with proper chemical treatment, including pressure-treated pine, it can stand strong against the elements. Pressure-treated pine is enhanced to resist rot and insect damage, making it a more durable choice for your average residential backyard fence.

Pressure-treated pine is treated with chemical preservatives to extend its lifespan. This treatment makes pine wood more resilient to harsh weather conditions and pest infestations. Pine fencing, when pressure treated, can last for many years, making it a cost-effective choice for homeowners.

Cedar Fences

Cedar, our suave contender, is naturally resistant to rot, decay, and pesky insects thanks to its natural oils. It's like it has a built-in security system. This durability cedar quality makes it a long-lasting choice for those who want to invest in a fence that will stand the test of time (and the occasional run-in with the lawnmower). Durability cedar qualities mean less maintenance and a longer lifespan without needing chemical treatments.

Cedar's natural oils also make it more resistant to moisture, which is especially beneficial in humid climates. Unlike pine, which can warp and crack over time if not properly maintained, cedar maintains its shape and strength. This makes cedar fencing an excellent choice for areas with varying weather conditions.

Round 3: Maintenance

Pine Fences

Pine fences require a bit more TLC. Regular sealing and staining are recommended to keep them looking sharp and to protect them from moisture and UV rays. Think of it like a skincare routine for your fence—necessary but totally worth it. However, the more maintenance required can be a downside. This is especially true for pine wood in humid climates, where frequent maintenance is essential.

Maintaining a pine fence involves using a water and soap solution for regular cleaning, followed by re-staining or sealing every couple of years. This process helps to protect the wood from the elements and extend its lifespan. While it does require more maintenance, a well-cared-for pine fence can look beautiful and serve its purpose for many years.

Cedar Fences

Cedar fencing is the low-maintenance option. Its natural oils protect it from moisture and insects, so you don't have to stress about frequent upkeep. A simple cleaning every now and then, and cedar is good to go. It’s like that friend who wakes up looking flawless with zero effort. Plus, the pleasant odor of cedar wood adds to its natural charm.

Cedar requires less maintenance than pine, making it an attractive option for homeowners looking for a beautiful yet low-maintenance solution. The occasional wash with a pressure washer and a light touch-up is usually all it needs to stay in top shape. This makes cedar fencing a practical choice for those with busy lifestyles.

Round 4: Cost

Pine Fences

Pine is the budget-friendly option, making it a popular choice for many homeowners. It's like getting a great deal on a top-notch coffee maker—affordable and reliable. Pine fencing is economical and effective, especially when you're working with a tight budget and looking for linear feet of fencing.

While pine may require more frequent maintenance and may have a shorter lifespan compared to cedar, its lower upfront cost can be a significant advantage. For large projects or for those looking to maximize their budget, pine fences provide a cost-effective solution that doesn’t compromise on aesthetics.

Cedar Fences

Cedar tends to be pricier, but you get what you pay for. It's an investment in quality and longevity. Think of it as splurging on a gourmet meal—you might pay more, but the experience is unforgettable. Cedar fencing's natural beauty and durability cedar properties make it worth the extra cost.

Investing in cedar fencing means you're paying for a material that will last longer and require less maintenance over time. This can save you money in the long run on repairs and replacements. The natural beauty of cedar and its superior durability make it a worthwhile investment for any homeowner.

Additional Considerations

Climate Considerations

When choosing between cedar and pine fences, consider your local climate. Humid climates can be tough on pine, even if it’s pressure treated. Cedar’s natural oils and durability make it more suitable for areas with high humidity and varying weather conditions.

Environmental Impact

Cedar wood is often sourced from sustainable forests, making it a more eco-friendly choice. Pine, especially pressure-treated pine, involves chemical treatments that may have a greater environmental impact. Choosing cedar can be a better option if you’re concerned about your environmental footprint.

Installation and Professional Help

Both cedar and pine fences require professional installation for the best results. The Fence Company offers expert fence installations to ensure your fence is built to last. Proper installation is key to maximizing the lifespan and performance of your fence, whether you choose cedar or pine.

The Verdict

So, who wins the epic cedar vs. pine showdown? The answer depends on what you value most. If you're looking for a cost-effective, classic option and don't mind putting in a bit of maintenance, a pine fence is your go-to. But if you want a durable, low-maintenance fence that exudes elegance, cedar is the way to go.

No matter which you choose, The Fence Company has you covered. We offer top-quality materials and expert fence installations to ensure your fence is the envy of the neighborhood. Ready to get started? Contact us today for a free consultation!

And remember, whether you're team pine or team cedar, a great wood fence makes great neighbors.

11 views0 comments


bottom of page